Strategy Consulting Needs To Change And This Is How

As a November 2019 article in The Economist suggests, strategy from the management consulting fields is beneath vital strain. Whereas it was one of many principal pillars of the big consulting companies—McKinsey & Firm, the Boston Consulting Group, Bain & Firm and so forth—it has develop into a marginal exercise now, accounting for about only a tenth of their revenues. Because the article explains, shoppers not need legions of consultants to supply them with recommendation. As an alternative they need them to place merchandise and applied sciences in place that preserve them forward of the competitors.

Lack of Relevance or Flawed Method

The observations in The Economist article might recommend two issues: that technique consulting is not related or that it isn’t performed the best method. Whereas some might argue for the primary, it’s clearly the second which is occurring. For full disclosure: a part of my job is being be a technique guide, that means {that a} vital a part of the work I do, is technique consulting. Whereas this was one thing to be proud and giving a little bit of standing, it appears to have progressively became one thing to virtually really feel embarrassed about. I do know of colleagues who keep away from the phrase technique altogether as a result of they really feel it makes them look old style or incapable of doing something concrete that actually helps organizations.

In its essential perspective in the direction of technique consulting and administration consulting extra usually, the current article in The Economist doesn’t stand in isolation. Actually, there’s a steady stream of critiques on which it stands. Illustrative are books about consulting, baring titles resembling The Witch Medical doctors (Micklethwait & Wooldridge, 1996), Harmful Firm (O’Shea & Madigan, 1998) and Consulting Demons (Pinault, 2009). As chances are you’ll infer from these titles, these books are usually not precisely constructive about consulting.

Entire-Mind, Entire-Individual Consulting

This implies change is required. And for locating instructions for what sort of change, we don’t should look far. We are able to simply take a look at what the consulting companies are saying themselves. As I summarized in two earlier articles, studies by Accenture and McKinsey plea for a whole-brain, whole-person method to management. Following their very own recommendations, this implies we additionally want whole-brain, whole-person technique consulting.

Rooted in engineering, present technique consulting is the head of left-brain considering. It’s rational-analytic, centered on decomposing issues into their most interesting particulars after which suppose up options of which the shopper may be satisfied to undertake them. That is most evident from McKinsey’s method as a result of it’s the greatest documented. However different consultancies apply it too.

Practiced as such, strategy consulting displays the way in which we historically take into consideration technique typically. As we discover in our textbooks, technique can be largely a rational-analytic exercise by which issues are analyzed with frameworks and options are thought up, that are then alleged to be adopted and executed by the group. However, as argued earlier in an article on The Ten Myths of Strategy, technique is just not like that.

If strategy from management consulting follows up on the consultancies’ personal recommendation, then a whole-brain, whole-person method is required. This implies first an method by which additionally the best facet of the mind performs a big position. This suggests there’s vital consideration to instinct, holistic judgment, creativity, empathy and self-awareness. It additionally signifies that not simply the mind, however all the pieces else that makes us an individual is concerned. This consists of our feelings and conscience in addition to our capability to truly do issues and create issues somewhat than merely suppose and speak.

In fact, virtually talking, technique consulting has all the time been a whole-brain, whole-person exercise. No particular person can change off the best facet of their mind or fully ignore their feelings or conscience. In any case, we’re all human beings, even technique consultants. However the strategies and methods of technique consulting have all the time had a robust bias in the direction of merely left-brain considering. As soon as these divulge heart’s contents to whole-brain, whole-person approaches, startegy consulting can deal with the evaluations it receives, regain its relevance and make a really constructive influence on organizations. So, time for consultancies to observe what they preach.

Credits: Jeroen Kraaijenbrink, Forbes.

Follow us